Hub Required vs No Hub Required Smart Home Controllers: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing hub required vs no hub required smart home controller options to find the right fit for your setup. Both devices automate your home, but they connect differently. The THIRDREALITY remote uses Zigbee and needs a hub, while the Amazon Basics plug uses Wi-Fi and connects directly to Alexa. This choice affects how you set up routines and which other devices can join your network. The main difference is the required infrastructure for each connection type.
Key differences
| Aspect | THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote | Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug |
|---|---|---|
| Connectivity | Zigbee 3.0 | 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi |
| Hub Requirement | Hub Required | No Hub Required |
| Smart Home Compatibility | Home Assistant, SmartThings, Homey | Alexa |
| Operating Environment | not listed | Outdoor, IP65 |
Which one should you choose?
Choose THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote if
- You already use Home Assistant or SmartThings and want to add a wireless button.
- You prefer a rechargeable battery over frequent replacements.
- You need multiple programmable actions from a single small device.
Choose Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug if
- You want to control outdoor devices without buying extra hardware.
- You only use Alexa and want a simple plug-and-play setup.
- You need weather-resistant equipment for outdoor use.
Verdict: Choose the THIRDREALITY remote if you use a multi-platform hub and want versatile automation. Pick the Amazon Basics plug if you rely solely on Alexa and need an outdoor solution. Your existing ecosystem determines the best path.
Hub Requirement Comparison
Connectivity
The THIRDREALITY remote relies on the Zigbee 3.0 standard for communication. This protocol typically requires a dedicated hub to bridge the signal to your home network. In contrast, the Amazon Basics plug connects directly via 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi. It does not need a separate hub to function. This direct Wi-Fi connection allows the plug to join your existing network without additional hardware. You must ensure your Wi-Fi is 2.4 GHz compatible for the plug to work. The remote needs a Zigbee-compatible hub like Home Assistant or SmartThings. Your existing network infrastructure determines which device fits better.
System Compatibility
Compatibility differs significantly between these two options. The Amazon Basics plug works exclusively with Alexa. You cannot use it with Google Home or Apple HomeKit. It is locked into the Amazon ecosystem. The THIRDREALITY remote supports multiple platforms. It is compatible with Home Assistant, SmartThings, and Homey. This broader support gives you more flexibility in choosing your smart home system. If you prefer a non-Amazon ecosystem, the remote is the better choice. The plug is only suitable if you are fully invested in Alexa.
Programmability
The THIRDREALITY remote offers extensive programmability with its three-button design. Each button supports three distinct actions: single press, double press, and hold. This provides up to nine unique routines per device. You can assign different commands to each action for lights or scenes. The Amazon Basics plug controls two outlets individually. You can group them in the Alexa app for simultaneous control. However, it lacks the multi-action input of the remote. The remote allows for complex scene triggering with simple physical inputs. The plug relies on voice or app commands for changes.
Power Source
Power management varies between the two devices. The THIRDREALITY remote uses a built-in rechargeable lithium battery. This eliminates the need for frequent battery replacements. You can recharge it when needed, offering long-term convenience. The Amazon Basics plug is powered directly by the electrical outlet. It draws power from the wall socket to operate the outlets and maintain its Wi-Fi connection. You do not need to charge it. However, it requires a constant power source. The remote is portable due to its battery, while the plug is stationary.
Build and Environment
Physical build and placement options differ. The Amazon Basics plug is rated IP65, making it weather-resistant. It is designed for outdoor use, protecting against water jets and spray. You can install it outside for garden lights or patio fans. The THIRDREALITY remote is an indoor device. Its compact size allows it to be placed anywhere without wiring. It is not rated for outdoor exposure. If you need outdoor control, the plug is the only option. For indoor automation, the remote offers flexible placement without electrical constraints.
Choose based on hub availability
Alexa users without extra hubs
You need a simple setup that works exclusively with Alexa. This plug connects via 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi without a hub. You get two independently controllable outlets for outdoor devices. The IP65 rating protects against water spray. You can schedule or control lights remotely using the Alexa app.
Home Assistant or SmartThings users
You already use a Zigbee hub like Home Assistant or SmartThings. This remote uses Zigbee 3.0 to integrate seamlessly with your existing ecosystem. You get three buttons with nine programmable actions. The rechargeable lithium battery reduces replacement needs. It is a compact, wireless solution for automating scenes.
Users wanting outdoor weather resistance
You need a device for outdoor use that withstands the elements. This plug features an IP65 rated enclosure against water jets and condensation. It connects directly via Wi-Fi to Alexa for voice control. You can manage two separate outlets for lights or appliances without adding a separate hub to your network.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote | Zigbee hub users wanting physical button control | Check price of THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote on Amazon |
| 2 | Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug | Alexa users needing weatherproof outdoor outlets | Check price of Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug on Amazon |
The products compared
THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote
Best for: Zigbee hub users wanting physical button control
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required (what this guide is about)
- Connectivity
- Zigbee 3.0
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Home Assistant, SmartThings, Homey
- Power Source
- Rechargeable lithium battery
- Dimensions
- 1.57 × 0.39 × 1.97 inches
View on Amazon: THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote Affiliate link
This THIRDREALITY unit is a wireless remote control powered by a rechargeable lithium battery. It uses Zigbee 3.0 connectivity, which means you must have a compatible hub like Home Assistant, SmartThings, or Homey to operate it. The device features three physical buttons, each supporting single, double, or hold actions. This allows you to program up to nine distinct routines for lights or scenes. It is designed for users who already have a Zigbee hub and want a simple, wired-free control option.
Pros
- Zigbee 3.0 connectivity for broad hub compatibility
- Three buttons with single, double, and hold actions
- Rechargeable lithium battery eliminates frequent replacements
- No wiring required for flexible placement
Cons
- Requires a separate Zigbee hub to function
- No built-in Wi-Fi for direct app control
- Limited to nine programmable routines per unit
Good fit if
- You already use a Zigbee hub like Home Assistant
- You want a simple physical button for routines
- You prefer not to replace batteries often
Skip if
- You do not have a Zigbee hub
- You need direct Wi-Fi connectivity
- You want a single-button remote only
Verdict: THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Button is a practical hub-dependent remote for users who already own a Zigbee bridge. It suits those who value physical buttons and rechargeable power over direct Wi-Fi integration.
Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug
Best for: Alexa users needing weatherproof outdoor outlets
- Hub Requirement
- No Hub Required (what this guide is about)
- Connectivity
- 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Alexa
- Network Interface
- 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi
- Operating Environment
- Outdoor, IP65
- Dimensions
- 3.72 × 1.81 × 4.94 inches
View on Amazon: Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug Affiliate link
This Amazon Basics outdoor plug offers two individually controlled outlets for voice and remote management. It connects via 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and requires no smart home hub. The IP65-rated enclosure protects against water jets and condensation. It works exclusively with Alexa, allowing you to schedule devices or create groups. This unit suits users who want simple, weather-resistant control for outdoor lighting without adding extra hardware to their network.
Pros
- Two independently controllable outlets
- No smart home hub required
- IP65 weather-resistant rating
- Works exclusively with Alexa
Cons
- Limited to Alexa ecosystem only
- Requires 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi connection
- No support for other voice assistants
Good fit if
- You use Alexa for voice control
- You need weather-resistant outdoor outlets
- You want to avoid extra hubs
Skip if
- You use Google Home or Apple HomeKit
- You need 5 GHz Wi-Fi support
- You require multi-ecosystem compatibility
Verdict: Amazon Basics Outdoor Smart Plug fits users who need reliable, weather-proof outlet control within the Alexa ecosystem. It avoids hub complexity but restricts you to Amazon's voice assistant.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | THIRDREALITY 3-Button Wireless Zigbee Remote | Amazon Basics 2-Outlet Outdoor Smart Plug |
|---|---|---|
| Connectivity | Zigbee 3.0 | 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi |
| Smart Home Compatibility | Home Assistant, SmartThings, Homey | Alexa |
| Network Interface | not stated | 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi |
| Operating Environment | not stated | Outdoor, IP65 |
| Power Source | Rechargeable lithium battery | not stated |
| Hub Requirement | Hub Required | No Hub Required |
| Dimensions | 1.57 × 0.39 × 1.97 inches | 3.72 × 1.81 × 4.94 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 9.95 ounces |
| Color | Black ZB2 1Pack | Black |
| Model | 3RSB01085Z | HPPA52CWBAMZ |
| Size | not stated | 3.71 x 1.81 x 5.04 in |
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a separate hub for Zigbee devices?
Yes, Zigbee devices require a dedicated hub to function. The THIRDREALITY remote uses the Zigbee protocol, which cannot connect directly to your Wi-Fi router. You must use a compatible bridge like SmartThings or Home Assistant to control it. Without this extra hardware, the remote will not respond to commands.
Can I use smart plugs without adding a hub?
Yes, Wi-Fi smart plugs work without a hub. The Amazon Basics Outdoor Smart Plug connects directly via 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi. You control it through the Alexa app or voice commands. This setup removes the need for additional hardware, making installation simpler for users who already own an Alexa-compatible ecosystem.
Is Zigbee better than Wi-Fi for home automation?
Zigbee offers a mesh network that can improve reliability, but it requires a hub. The THIRDREALITY remote leverages this for stable control. Wi-Fi devices like the Amazon Basics plug connect directly to your router. They are easier to set up but may increase network traffic. Choose Zigbee for dedicated hubs and Wi-Fi for simplicity.
What happens if I lose my Wi-Fi connection?
Wi-Fi devices like the Amazon Basics plug may stop responding if your internet goes down. Zigbee devices connected to a local hub, such as the THIRDREALITY remote, often continue working. The hub processes commands locally. This makes Zigbee more resilient for critical automations, while Wi-Fi devices depend entirely on your router's status.
Do I need a specific voice assistant for these devices?
It depends on the device. The Amazon Basics plug is restricted to Alexa. It does not work with other assistants. The THIRDREALITY remote works with SmartThings and Home Assistant. You can integrate it with various voice platforms through those hubs. Check your existing ecosystem before buying to ensure compatibility.
Can I control outdoor devices without a hub?
Yes, the Amazon Basics Outdoor Smart Plug works without a hub. It features an IP65 rating for weather resistance. You control it via Wi-Fi and Alexa. This allows you to manage outdoor lights or fans directly. No additional bridge is needed, making it a straightforward choice for outdoor automation projects.