Looking Beyond the Enbrighten In-Wall Motion Sensor Smart? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The enbrighten z wave smart motion sensor alternatives list helps you find better options if the Enbrighten switch does not fit your setup. That model offers occupancy modes, light sensing, and range extension via Z-Wave. It requires a neutral wire and a hub. You might need something different if your electrical box is too small for a standard switch. You may also prefer a different protocol like Zigbee or need no-neutral wiring. Some users simply want a dimmer plug instead of an in-wall device. Other buyers seek a relay that automates existing switches without replacing the hardware. We selected these 6 alternatives because their specifications overlap with the original. Each product shares key traits like hub compatibility or smart home integration. This guide compares their published specs to help you decide. You can see how each option handles connectivity, size, and wiring requirements. The goal is to match your specific home automation needs. Look for the right balance of features and form factor. Your existing hub and wiring constraints will dictate the best choice. This list highlights practical differences in design and function. Read on to find the device that suits your space and system.
Our top pick: Enbrighten In-Wall Motion Sensor Smart Switch.
How each alternative compares
Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug
The Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug replaces wall switches with an outlet-based solution. It lacks motion sensing entirely, focusing instead on dimming capabilities for lamps. You plug it directly into existing outlets rather than wiring it into the wall. This device requires a hub and works with Alexa, SmartThings, and Home Assistant. Its compact dimensions of 1.18 by 1.46 inches allow it to fit in tight spaces where standard plugs fail. If you need precise light control without installing new hardware, this plug offers a simpler alternative to the Enbrighten switch, though it does not extend Z-Wave range as effectively.
SONOFF Zigbee Mini Smart Switch 2-Pack
The SONOFF Zigbee Mini Smart Switch operates on the Zigbee protocol instead of Z-Wave. This fundamental difference means it cannot replace the Enbrighten switch if your hub only supports Z-Wave. It is a small module designed to hide behind existing switches, adding Zigbee capacity to your network. The device requires a neutral wire and a compatible hub. It supports Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings. Its tiny form factor measures 1.3 by 1.56 inches. You should choose this option if you are expanding a Zigbee mesh rather than seeking motion detection. It provides basic on/off control without the occupancy sensors or light-sensing features found in the Enbrighten model.
SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch
The SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch removes the neutral wire requirement that the Enbrighten model demands. This makes it suitable for older electrical boxes lacking neutral conductors. It connects via Zigbee, so it requires a Zigbee hub rather than a Z-Wave hub. The device is extremely compact, measuring 1.25 by 0.72 inches, allowing installation in tight spaces. It supports Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings. You lose motion sensing and light-sensing capabilities with this switch. It offers basic remote control instead. If your wiring setup prevents the use of a neutral wire, this SONOFF unit provides a viable path to smart control where the Enbrighten switch cannot be installed.
Zooz 700 Series Z-Wave In-Wall Smart Relay
The Zooz 700 Series Z-Wave In-Wall Smart Relay automates existing non-smart switches rather than replacing them. It operates on Z-Wave, matching the Enbrighten network protocol. This device requires a hub and works with SmartThings and Home Assistant. It lacks motion detection, focusing solely on remote control of legacy switches. Its small size of 1.4 by 0.7 inches allows it to fit inside standard electrical boxes. You gain long-range Z-Wave reliability and 3-way support. This option suits users who want to keep their existing switch aesthetics while adding smart functionality. It does not offer the occupancy modes or manual override features of the Enbrighten motion sensor switch.
New One 800 Series Mini Smart Plug 2-Pack
The New One 800 Series Mini Smart Plug provides Z-Wave connectivity through an outlet rather than a wall switch. It lacks motion sensing and requires a hub. This device supports SmartThings and offers strong range extension for your Z-Wave mesh. Its compact dimensions of 1.46 by 1.02 inches help it fit in tight outlet spaces. You get secure, high-load outlet control instead of light switching. The unit weighs 4.8 ounces. This alternative is ideal if you need to automate lamps or appliances without any wiring changes. It does not replace the Enbrighten switch if you require in-wall installation with occupancy detection and light-sensing automation features.
Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer
The Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer controls two loads from a single wall opening. It uses Z-Wave connectivity and requires a hub. This device supports SmartThings and Home Assistant. It lacks motion sensing, offering independent dimming for lights and relay control for fans instead. The unit measures 1.7 by 4.1 inches, fitting standard wall plates. You gain advanced automation for dual-load setups without needing dual-gang modifications. This option suits users who want to control ceiling fans and lights separately. It does not provide the occupancy modes or light-sensing capabilities of the Enbrighten switch, focusing instead on precise load management for complex fixtures.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Enbrighten In-Wall Motion Sensor Smart Switch
Best for: Z-Wave indoor motion sensing with range extension
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Alexa, SmartThings, Wink
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required
- Connectivity
- Z-Wave
- Wiring Requirement
- Neutral Required
- Circuit Type
- Single Pole, Multi-Switch
- Switch Function
- Motion Sensor, On/Off Switch
View on Amazon: Enbrighten In-Wall Motion Sensor Smart Switch Affiliate link
This Enbrighten switch combines motion sensing with on/off control using Z-Wave connectivity. It requires a neutral wire and a hub. You can choose between occupancy, vacancy, or manual modes. The device includes white and almond buttons. It supports Alexa and SmartThings. The unit extends your Z-Wave range by up to 150 feet. It fits standard single-pole or multi-switch setups.
Pros
- Three motion-detection modes: occupancy, vacancy, and manual
- Adjustable time-out from 5 seconds to 30 minutes
- Includes white and light almond changeable buttons
- Repeats Z-Wave signal to extend range by 150ft
- Compatible with Alexa and SmartThings
Cons
- Requires a neutral wire for installation
- Requires a Z-Wave hub to function
- Indoor use only
Good fit if
- You need a Z-Wave motion sensor with on/off control
- You want to extend your Z-Wave network range
- You prefer physical buttons that match your decor
Skip if
- You do not have a neutral wire at the switch box
- You lack a Z-Wave hub for automation
- You need outdoor-rated weatherproofing
Verdict: Enbrighten Z-Wave Motion Sensor Light Switch offers flexible motion modes and range extension for Z-Wave users. It suits those with neutral wires who want reliable indoor automation via Alexa or SmartThings.
Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug
Best for: Dimming lamps in tight outlet spaces
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Alexa, Google Assistant, SmartThings
- Hub Requirement
- Z-Wave Hub Required
- Connectivity
- Z-Wave
- Wiring Requirement
- No wiring required
- Switch Function
- Dimmer
- Maximum Load
- 200W Incandescent, 100W CFL/LED
View on Amazon: Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug Affiliate link
The Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug offers 1-100% dimming control for lamps and dimmable LEDs. It features a compact design that allows two units in one outlet. The device includes a built-in repeater to extend wireless range up to 1300 feet with a compatible hub. It supports S2 authenticated security and SmartStart pairing. You need a Z-Wave hub to use this plug-in outlet.
Pros
- 1-100% dimming range for adjustable lighting
- Compact size fits two plugs per outlet
- Built-in repeater extends range up to 1300ft
- SmartStart simplifies hub pairing setup
- Supports voice control with Alexa and Google Assistant
Cons
- Requires a Z-Wave hub for operation
- Limited to 200W incandescent or 100W LED loads
- Cannot connect directly to Echo Plus devices
Good fit if
- You want to dim lamps or LED lights remotely
- You need a compact plug that does not block adjacent outlets
- You already have a Z-Wave hub for home automation
Skip if
- You do not have a Z-Wave hub
- You need to control non-dimmable bulbs
- You want direct connection without a hub
Verdict: The Minoston Z-Wave Dimmer Plug is a practical choice for users who need precise light control and space-saving design. It suits those with existing Z-Wave networks who want to add dimmable lighting without complex wiring.
SONOFF Zigbee Mini Smart Switch 2-Pack
Best for: expanding Zigbee network capacity
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings
- Hub Requirement
- Zigbee 3.0 Gateway Hub Required
- Connectivity
- Zigbee 3.0
- Wiring Requirement
- Neutral Required
- Maximum Load
- 10A
- Dimensions
- 0.66 × 1.3 × 1.56 inches
View on Amazon: SONOFF Zigbee Mini Smart Switch 2-Pack Affiliate link
This compact Zigbee 3.0 switch expands your smart home network while controlling standard lighting. It requires a neutral wire and a dedicated Zigbee gateway hub to function. The device supports up to 64 connected devices and integrates with Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings. Its small form factor fits inside most standard electrical boxes. It is ideal for users who need to extend their Zigbee range or add reliable single-channel control.
Pros
- Zigbee 3.0 protocol for stable network integration
- Supports up to 64 devices on one gateway
- Compatible with Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings
- Compact 1.3 by 1.56 inch size fits standard boxes
Cons
- Requires a neutral wire for installation
- Needs a separate Zigbee gateway hub
- Single channel limits control to one load
Good fit if
- You need to expand your Zigbee device capacity
- You have a neutral wire available in the box
- You use a Zigbee hub like SmartThings or Alexa
Skip if
- You do not have a neutral wire
- You want to control without a hub
- You need multi-way switching support
Verdict: SONOFF ZBMINIR2 Zigbee Smart Switch is a small, hub-dependent controller that adds range and capacity to your Zigbee network. It fits best in homes with neutral wiring and existing smart hubs.
SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch
Best for: tight electrical boxes and no-neutral wiring
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required
- Connectivity
- Zigbee 3.0
- Wiring Requirement
- No Neutral Required
- Circuit Type
- 2-Way
- Dimensions
- 1.55 × 1.25 × 0.72 inches
View on Amazon: SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch Affiliate link
This SONOFF ZBMINI Extreme is a compact Zigbee 3.0 smart switch designed for tight spaces. It measures just 1.25 by 0.72 by 1.55 inches, allowing it to fit into small EU, 86, or 120 type mounting boxes. The unit requires no neutral wire and works with external rocker or push-button switches. You need a Zigbee hub to control it via Alexa, Google Home, or SmartThings. It supports two-way control and basic scheduling.
Pros
- Extremely small dimensions fit tight mounting boxes
- No neutral wire required for easier installation
- Supports two-way control with external switches
- Compatible with Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings
Cons
- Requires a separate Zigbee hub to function
- Only supports on/off switching, no dimming
- Physical size limits heat dissipation for high loads
Good fit if
- You have small electrical boxes with limited space
- You want to add smart control without rewiring
- You already use a Zigbee hub for other devices
Skip if
- You need a hub-free setup
- You require dimming capabilities
- You prefer Wi-Fi connectivity over Zigbee
Verdict: SONOFF ZBMINI Extreme Tiny Zigbee Switch fits into tight spaces where standard switches fail. It is a practical solution for you if you need to retrofit small boxes with smart control using your existing Zigbee hub.
Zooz 700 Series Z-Wave In-Wall Smart Relay
Best for: Automating existing wall switches with long-range Z-Wave
- Smart Home Compatibility
- SmartThings, Hubitat, Home Assistant
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required
- Connectivity
- Z-Wave, Z-Wave Long Range
- Wiring Requirement
- Neutral Required
- Circuit Type
- 3-Way
- Switch Function
- On/Off Switch
View on Amazon: Zooz 700 Series Z-Wave In-Wall Smart Relay Affiliate link
The Zooz ZEN51 is a compact smart relay that installs behind existing wall switches. It adds Z-Wave and Z-Wave Long Range control to standard on/off switches. The device requires a neutral wire and a compatible hub. It supports 3-way setups and SmartStart pairing. This relay suits users who want to keep their current switch aesthetic while automating lighting or monitoring 120V signals like sump pumps.
Pros
- Supports Z-Wave Long Range for extended mesh coverage
- Compact dimensions of 1.5 x 1.4 x 0.7 inches fit crowded boxes
- Enables 3-way switch configurations without neutral at the switch location
- Smart Bulb Mode maintains switch functionality with smart bulbs
- Includes a 5-year warranty upon registration
Cons
- Requires a neutral wire for installation
- Incompatible with dimmer or electronic smart switches at the input
- Requires a hub that supports Z-Wave Long Range features
Good fit if
- You want to automate existing mechanical switches without replacing them
- You have a neutral wire available in the switch box
- You need 3-way switching capability for your lighting circuit
Skip if
- You do not have a neutral wire in your switch box
- You plan to use dimmer switches with this relay
- You want a standalone smart switch rather than a relay
Verdict: The Zooz ZEN51 Z-Wave Long Range Relay is a precise automation tool for upgrading legacy switches. It fits users who need long-range Z-Wave reliability and 3-way support in a small form factor.
New One 800 Series Mini Smart Plug 2-Pack
Best for: extending Z-Wave range with secure outlets
- Smart Home Compatibility
- SmartThings, Vera, Wink, Fibaro, Alexa
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required
- Connectivity
- 800 Series Z-Wave
- Maximum Load
- 1875W
- Dimensions
- 2.99 × 1.46 × 1.02 inches
- Weight
- 4.8 ounces
View on Amazon: New One 800 Series Mini Smart Plug 2-Pack Affiliate link
This 2-pack of New One smart plugs uses 800 Series Z-Wave technology to extend your network range up to 1300 feet in open areas. You get S2 security encryption and the ability to act as repeaters for up to four signal layers. The compact design allows two plugs in one outlet, supporting loads up to 1875W. It requires a Z-Wave hub for operation and works with major platforms like SmartThings and Hubitat.
Pros
- 800 Series Z-Wave extends range up to 1300 feet
- S2 security with unique QR code matching
- Compact design fits two plugs in one outlet
- Acts as Z-Wave repeater for up to 4 layers
- Supports up to 1875W maximum load
Cons
- Requires a separate Z-Wave hub to function
- Repeater function limited to 4 signal layers
- Not compatible with Echo Plus or Vivint Hub
Good fit if
- You need to extend Z-Wave network range
- You want to use S2 security encryption
- You have limited outlet space
Skip if
- You do not have a Z-Wave hub
- You need compatibility with Echo Plus
- You require a dimmer outlet
Verdict: New One 800 Series Z-Wave Smart Plug 2 Pack offers strong range extension and security for users with compatible hubs. It is ideal for those needing compact, high-load outlets that also boost their Z-Wave mesh network.
Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer
Best for: single-gang dual fan and light control
- Smart Home Compatibility
- Home Assistant, Hubitat, SmartThings
- Hub Requirement
- Hub Required
- Connectivity
- 800 Series Z-Wave Long Range
- Wiring Requirement
- NEUTRAL WIRE REQUIRED
- Circuit Type
- Virtual 3-way
- Switch Function
- Dimmer
View on Amazon: Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer Affiliate link
This in-wall switch controls two separate loads from a single gang box using 800 Series Z-Wave Long Range. You get a 75-watt LED dimmer for lighting alongside a 15-amp relay button for exhaust or ceiling fans. It suits you if you need independent fan and light control through your Z-Wave hub without cutting an extra wall box opening.
Pros
- Controls two independent loads from a single-gang switch location
- 800 Series Z-Wave Long Range offers extended range and mesh repeating
- 15A relay capacity handles ceiling and exhaust fan loads
- Shallow 1.1-inch housing depth fits crowded electrical boxes
Cons
- Fan relay operates as on/off only with no fan speed control
- Dimmer load limit is capped at 75 watts for LED bulbs
- Incompatible with Z-Wave alarm panels such as Ring, Vivint, and ADT
Good fit if
- You have a single-gang box with a neutral wire powering both a light and a fan.
- You run a compatible hub such as Home Assistant, Hubitat, or SmartThings.
- You want 800 Series Z-Wave Long Range direct-to-hub transmission.
Skip if
- You need multi-speed ceiling fan control.
- You do not have a neutral wire in your wall box.
- You manage your home automation through Ring, ADT, or Vivint alarm hubs.
Verdict: Zooz Z-Wave Long Range Double Switch fits dual-load setups where you want independent control of a dimmable light and a fan relay from one wall opening. It gives advanced hub owners flexible automation options without requiring dual-gang modifications.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Enbrighten In-Wall Motion Sensor Smart Switch | Minoston 800 Series Z-Wave Dimmer Plug | SONOFF Zigbee Mini Smart Switch 2-Pack | SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch | Zooz 700 Series Z-Wave In-Wall Smart Relay | New One 800 Series Mini Smart Plug 2-Pack | Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smart Home Compatibility | Alexa, SmartThings, Wink | Alexa, Google Assistant, SmartThings | Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings | Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings | SmartThings, Hubitat, Home Assistant | SmartThings, Vera, Wink, Fibaro, Alexa | Home Assistant, Hubitat, SmartThings |
| Hub Requirement | Hub Required | Z-Wave Hub Required | Zigbee 3.0 Gateway Hub Required | Hub Required | Hub Required | Hub Required | Hub Required |
| Connectivity | Z-Wave | Z-Wave | Zigbee 3.0 | Zigbee 3.0 | Z-Wave, Z-Wave Long Range | 800 Series Z-Wave | 800 Series Z-Wave Long Range |
| Wiring Requirement | Neutral Required | No wiring required | Neutral Required | No Neutral Required | Neutral Required | not stated | NEUTRAL WIRE REQUIRED |
| Circuit Type | Single Pole, Multi-Switch | not stated | not stated | 2-Way | 3-Way | not stated | Virtual 3-way |
| Switch Function | Motion Sensor, On/Off Switch | Dimmer | not stated | not stated | On/Off Switch | not stated | Dimmer |
| Maximum Load | not stated | 200W Incandescent, 100W CFL/LED | 10A | not stated | not stated | 1875W | 75W LED, 15A |
| Operating Environment | Indoor | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 1.5 × 1.5 × 3 inches | 2.52 × 1.18 × 1.46 inches | 0.66 × 1.3 × 1.56 inches | 1.55 × 1.25 × 0.72 inches | 1.5 × 1.4 × 0.7 inches | 2.99 × 1.46 × 1.02 inches | not stated |
| Weight | 6.4 ounces | 2.08 ounces | not stated | not stated | not stated | 4.8 ounces | not stated |
| Size | 1 Pack | 1Pack | ef of 2 pk | ZBMINIL2 2-Pack | not stated | New Mini Outlet 2 Pack | 1.7" x 4.1" x 1.1" |
| Color | White & Light Almond | White | not stated | White | not stated | White | White |
| Model | 26931 | MP31ZD | ZBMINIR2-2PACK | ZBMINIL2 | ZEN51 | N4011-2 | ZEN30 800LR |
If you prefer hardwired detection hardware, you can compare safeguard supply wired informer motion sensor alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Can these alternatives work without a smart home hub?
No, every listed device requires a hub. The Enbrighten, Minoston, SONOFF, Zooz, and New One products all specify a hub requirement in their attributes. You cannot connect them directly to Wi-Fi or Bluetooth. You must have a compatible Z-Wave or Zigbee hub to control these switches and plugs remotely.
Do any of these options detect motion automatically?
None of the alternatives listed here include motion sensors. The Enbrighten model is the only one with built-in occupancy sensing. The Minoston dimmer plug, SONOFF switches, Zooz relays, and New One plug are purely control devices. You would need a separate motion sensor to trigger automation with these items.
Which devices support Google Home or Alexa?
Most options support both major voice assistants. The SONOFF Zigbee Mini Switch and No-Neutral Switch list Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings compatibility. The Enbrighten switch supports Alexa and SmartThings. The Minoston dimmer also works with Home Assistant. The Zooz and New One devices focus on SmartThings and Home Assistant.
Which switch works if I do not have a neutral wire?
The SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch is designed for this scenario. Its attributes explicitly state it requires no neutral wire. This makes it suitable for tight electrical boxes where standard wiring is unavailable. Other listed devices like the Enbrighten and SONOFF Mini Switch generally require neutral wiring for stable operation.
Can I use these with SmartThings or Home Assistant?
Yes, most devices support these platforms. The Enbrighten, SONOFF, Minoston, Zooz, and New One products all list compatibility with SmartThings. The Minoston, SONOFF, and Zooz devices also support Home Assistant. This broad compatibility allows you to integrate these controls into various smart home ecosystems without vendor lock-in.
Which option is best for tight electrical boxes?
The SONOFF No-Neutral Zigbee Switch and the Zooz 700 Series Relay are ideal for small spaces. The SONOFF unit measures 0.72 inches in height. The Zooz relay is 0.7 inches tall. Both are significantly smaller than standard wall switches, allowing installation in compact junction boxes where larger devices would not fit.
Do these devices extend the range of my smart network?
Yes, several models act as range extenders. The Enbrighten switch and New One plug boost Z-Wave mesh networks. The SONOFF Zigbee Mini Switch expands Zigbee capacity. These devices repeat signals, improving connectivity for other sensors and switches in your home. This is useful for large homes with many smart devices.
Which device controls both a fan and a light?
The Zooz Double Switch Fan and Light Dimmer handles dual loads. It allows independent control of a dimmable light and a fan relay from a single wall opening. This is useful for ceiling fan installations where you want separate controls without installing two separate switches. It requires a Z-Wave hub.