6 Best Alternatives to the Enbrighten Toggle Add-On Switch 2-Pack (2026)

How each alternative compares

THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Plug 4-Pack

The THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Plug 4-Pack offers a different approach by automating devices via outlets rather than wall switches. It connects through Zigbee hubs, similar to the Enbrighten add-on, but provides a compact 1.5 by 1.1 by 2.6-inch form factor. This white plug suits users who need to automate multiple appliances or lamps without touching existing wiring. Unlike the Enbrighten switch, it does not replace wall controls. It is better for renters or those who prefer plug-in flexibility. The Enbrighten unit remains superior for hardwired three-way lighting setups. You choose this plug if you want to control non-permanent devices or need more outlets than switches.

SONOFF Compact Zigbee Smart Switch

The SONOFF Compact Zigbee Smart Switch is a tiny white relay measuring 1.68 by 1.68 by 0.79 inches. It fits inside tight electrical boxes where the larger Enbrighten switch might not. This device requires a Zigbee hub and works with Alexa and Google Home. It is designed to be hidden behind existing wall switches, preserving your current toggle style. The Enbrighten add-on sits on the wall surface, while the SONOFF hides inside the box. You should pick the SONOFF if your electrical box is shallow or cramped. It gives up the visible toggle interface for a cleaner, hidden installation. The Enbrighten is better if you want a visible, replaceable wall component that matches your decor.

Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 Smart Relay Switch

The Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 Smart Relay Switch is a compact blue relay measuring 1.34 by 1.14 by 0.63 inches. It weighs only 0.71 ounces. This unit supports Zigbee and Matter, offering hub-free control options unlike the Enbrighten which requires a hub. It is ideal for retrofitting tight spaces with minimal bulk. The Shelly is smaller and lighter than the Enbrighten add-on switch. It suits users who need flexible automation for lights or small devices without a dedicated hub. The Enbrighten is better for traditional three-way toggle setups that need visible add-on switches. You choose the Shelly if you want a hidden, ultra-compact solution with modern Matter support.

THIRDREALITY Zigbee No-Wiring Smart Switch

The THIRDREALITY Zigbee No-Wiring Smart Switch 2-Pack is a white rocker switch measuring 0.77 by 1.77 by 4.72 inches. It weighs 3.53 ounces. This device requires a Zigbee hub and works with SmartThings and Home Assistant. It is designed for retrofitting standard switches without changing wiring. Unlike the Enbrighten add-on, which adds to existing switches, this replaces the switch faceplate entirely. It is better for users who want a clean rocker style instead of a toggle. The Enbrighten preserves your existing toggle mechanism. You pick this THIRDREALITY unit if you prefer a rocker interface and want to avoid modifying internal wiring. It offers a different aesthetic and control style.

Shelly 2PM Gen4 2-Channel Relay

The Shelly 2PM Gen4 2-Channel Relay is a black relay measuring 1.65 by 1.46 by 0.63 inches. It weighs 0.92 ounces. This unit supports Zigbee and provides independent control and energy monitoring for two circuits. It fits users who need detailed power tracking for hardwired appliances. Unlike the Enbrighten add-on switch, which controls lighting circuits via wall toggles, this relay monitors energy usage. It is better for users who want to track consumption of two separate devices. The Enbrighten is better for simple lighting control without monitoring. You choose the Shelly 2PM if you need data on power usage and independent circuit management. It lacks the visible toggle interface of the Enbrighten.

Shelly 1PM Gen4 Relay Switch with Power Metering

The Shelly 1PM Gen4 Relay Switch with Power Metering is a red relay measuring 1.65 by 1.46 by 0.63 inches. It weighs 0.92 ounces. This unit supports Zigbee and Matter, offering energy tracking for hardwired appliances. It fits users who install smart controls behind existing wall plates. Unlike the Enbrighten add-on switch, which is a visible wall component, this relay is hidden. It provides detailed energy monitoring that the Enbrighten does not. It is better for users who need to track power usage of specific devices. The Enbrighten is better for traditional three-way lighting setups. You pick the Shelly 1PM if you want hidden installation with power data. It lacks the toggle style of the Enbrighten.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Enbrighten Toggle Add-On Switch 2-Pack

Best for: Upgrading traditional three-way toggle setups

Connectivity

Z-Wave, Zigbee

Dimensions

4.1 × 1.9 × 1.7 inches

View on Amazon: Enbrighten Toggle Add-On Switch 2-Pack Affiliate link

This is a pair of Enbrighten add-on switches designed for three-way setups. You must pair them with a primary smart control. They support Z-Wave and Zigbee protocols. The QuickFit design reduces housing depth by 20%. SimpleWire technology uses offset ground ports to avoid mounting screws. The light almond finish matches standard home decor. This fits you if you want to automate existing toggle switches without rewiring.

Pros

• Supports both Z-Wave and Zigbee protocols
• QuickFit design reduces housing depth by 20%
• SimpleWire technology features offset ground ports
• Compatible with 120VAC and 277VAC controls
• Light almond finish matches existing decor

Cons

• Not a standalone switch; requires a primary smart control
• Limited to three-way setups only
• Wallplates are not included

Good fit if

• You want to upgrade a traditional three-way toggle setup
• You already use a Z-Wave or Zigbee hub
• You need a slim fit for shallow electrical boxes

Skip if

• You need a single switch that works independently
• You only have Wi-Fi smart home devices
• You prefer a rocker style over a toggle style

Verdict: Enbrighten QuickFit Add-On Switch 2-Pack is a practical solution for automating existing three-way toggle switches. It suits users who already have a compatible hub and want a slim, easy-to-install upgrade for their walls.

2 Also great

THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Plug 4-Pack

Best for: automating multiple devices via Zigbee hubs

Smart Home Compatibility

Apple HomeKit, Google Home, Alexa

Hub Requirement

Requires ZigBee Hub

Connectivity

Zigbee

Maximum Load

15A

Dimensions

2.6 × 1.5 × 1.1 inches

View on Amazon: THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Plug 4-Pack Affiliate link

This product is a set of four compact smart plugs designed for Zigbee networks. It supports a maximum load of 15A and connects via Zigbee rather than Wi-Fi. You can control the plugs using voice commands with Alexa, Google Home, or Apple HomeKit, provided you have a compatible hub or Echo device. The compact design ensures it does not block adjacent outlets. This pack suits users who want to automate multiple appliances without Wi-Fi congestion.

Pros

• Zigbee connectivity reduces Wi-Fi network congestion
• Compact design saves space on outlet panels
• Supports scheduling and timer functions
• Compatible with Apple HomeKit, Google Home, and Alexa

Cons

• Requires a Zigbee hub for full smart home integration
• No native Wi-Fi connection option
• Apple HomeKit support requires a separate Smart Bridge

Good fit if

• You want to add multiple smart outlets without straining your Wi-Fi
• You already use a Zigbee hub like SmartThings or Hubitat
• You need compact plugs that do not block neighboring sockets

Skip if

• You prefer direct Wi-Fi control without a hub
• You want to use this with Apple HomeKit but lack a Smart Bridge
• You need a single plug instead of a four-pack

Verdict: THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Plug 4 Pack offers a reliable, hub-dependent solution for automating multiple devices. It is ideal for users with existing Zigbee ecosystems who need compact, high-load outlets.

3 Best budget

SONOFF Compact Zigbee Smart Switch

Best for: tight electrical boxes and external switch use

Smart Home Compatibility

Alexa, Google Home

Hub Requirement

Zigbee Hub Required

Connectivity

Zigbee 3.0

Wiring Requirement

Neutral Line Required

Circuit Type

Two-way

Dimensions

1.68 × 1.68 × 0.79 inches

View on Amazon: SONOFF Compact Zigbee Smart Switch Affiliate link

This tiny Zigbee 3.0 smart switch fits into small EU, 86, or 120 type mounting boxes. It measures 1.68 by 0.79 inches. You need a Zigbee hub to connect it. It works with Alexa and Google Home. The device supports two-way control and external switches. It handles lights as low as 3W without flickering. It is ideal for tight spaces.

Pros

• Zigbee 3.0 connectivity for reliable local control
• Supports external rocker or push button switches
• Compatible with Alexa and Google Home voice commands
• Handles low-wattage lights down to 3W

Cons

• Requires a separate Zigbee hub for operation
• Only controls one circuit at a time
• No neutral wire requirement noted in features

Good fit if

• You have small electrical boxes in your walls
• You want to use existing wall switches with smart control
• You already have a Zigbee hub in your home

Skip if

• You need Wi-Fi connectivity without a hub
• You require multi-gang control in a single device
• You prefer a plug-and-play setup without extra hardware

Verdict: SONOFF ZBMINIR2 Tiny Zigbee Switch fits tight electrical boxes and works with existing wall switches. It suits users who already own a Zigbee hub and want compact smart control.

4 Also great

Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 Smart Relay Switch

Best for: retrofitting tight spaces with hub-free control

Smart Home Compatibility

Matter, Alexa, SmartThings, Google Home

Hub Requirement

No Hub Required

Connectivity

Wi-Fi, Zigbee

Switch Function

Relay Switch

Maximum Load

8A

Dimensions

0.63 × 1.34 × 1.14 inches

View on Amazon: Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 Smart Relay Switch Affiliate link

The Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 is a compact Wi-Fi and Zigbee smart relay. It supports Matter and requires no hub. With an 8A load capacity, it fits inside standard switch boxes or appliances. Its small size allows for easy retrofitting. You can control it via the Shelly Smart Control App. This device suits users who need flexible automation for lights or small devices.

Pros

• Wi-Fi and Zigbee connectivity without a hub
• Matter support for broad compatibility
• Compact dimensions fit tight spaces
• 8A maximum load capacity
• Includes 3-year device warranty

Cons

• Single-channel 1-ampere limit
• No physical toggle or rocker switch
• Requires external wiring for installation

Good fit if

• You want hub-free Wi-Fi and Zigbee control
• You need Matter compatibility for future-proofing
• You are retrofitting into tight switch boxes

Skip if

• You require a physical toggle or rocker switch
• You need to control high-power appliances over 8A
• You prefer a simple plug-and-play outlet

Verdict: Shelly 1 Mini Gen4 Smart Relay is a compact, hub-free smart switch ideal for retrofitting tight spaces. It fits users who need Matter support and flexible automation for lights or small devices.

5 Best premium

THIRDREALITY Zigbee No-Wiring Smart Switch

Best for: retrofitting standard switches without wiring changes

Smart Home Compatibility

Echo, Home Assistant, SmartThings, Homey

Hub Requirement

Hub Required

Connectivity

Zigbee

Wiring Requirement

No Neutral Required

Switch Style

Rocker

Dimensions

1.77 × 0.77 × 4.72 inches

View on Amazon: THIRDREALITY Zigbee No-Wiring Smart Switch Affiliate link

This device snaps over an existing toggle or rocker switch to automate lighting without new wiring. It runs on two AAA batteries and connects via Zigbee, requiring a compatible hub like Echo or SmartThings. The narrow 0.77-inch width allows it to fit 2-gang switches. It supports voice control and scheduling for energy savings. This is a practical solution for retrofitting standard switches with smart features.

Pros

• No wiring or neutral wire required for installation
• Narrow 0.77-inch width fits 2-gang switches
• Compatible with Zigbee hubs and Echo devices
• Mechanical control works independently of Wi-Fi

Cons

• Requires a separate Zigbee hub to function
• Uses disposable AAA batteries instead of hardwired power
• Not compatible with Tuya ecosystem

Good fit if

• You want to automate a switch without hiring an electrician
• You already own a Zigbee hub or Echo device
• You need a slim profile for multi-gang switch plates

Skip if

• You prefer a hardwired device that never needs battery changes
• You rely exclusively on the Tuya smart home platform
• You need direct Wi-Fi connectivity without a hub

Verdict: THIRDREALITY Zigbee Smart Switch 2-Pack offers a reliable retrofit solution for users who already have a Zigbee hub. It is best for renters or homeowners who want to add automation to existing switches without modifying wiring.

6 Also great

Shelly 2PM Gen4 2-Channel Relay

Best for: Dual-circuit energy monitoring and control

Smart Home Compatibility

Alexa, Google Home, Apple HomeKit

Hub Requirement

No Hub Required

Connectivity

Wi-Fi, Zigbee, Matter, Bluetooth

Maximum Load

16A per channel

Dimensions

0.63 × 1.65 × 1.46 inches

Weight

0.92 ounces

View on Amazon: Shelly 2PM Gen4 2-Channel Relay Affiliate link

The Shelly 2PM Gen4 is a dual-channel smart relay switch supporting Wi-Fi, Zigbee, and Matter. It handles up to 16A per channel and includes built-in power metering for individual energy tracking. You can control two separate circuits independently using the app, voice commands, or manual switches. It requires no hub and integrates with major smart home platforms like Alexa and Google Home.

Pros

• Dual 16A channels for independent control
• Built-in power metering per channel
• Wi-Fi, Zigbee, and Matter support
• No hub required for operation

Cons

• Larger physical size than single-channel relays
• Non-UL certified variant available
• Requires external wiring for installation

Good fit if

• You need to monitor energy use for two separate circuits
• You want a hub-free setup with Matter support
• You are installing a relay in a junction box

Skip if

• You require a UL-certified device for your installation
• You need a simple single-pole wall switch replacement
• You prefer a compact device that fits in tight spaces

Verdict: Shelly 2PM Gen4 2-Channel Relay fits users who need independent control and energy monitoring for two circuits without a hub.

7 Best no hub required

Shelly 1PM Gen4 Relay Switch with Power Metering

Best for: Energy monitoring of hardwired appliances

Smart Home Compatibility

Matter, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings

Hub Requirement

No Hub Required

Connectivity

Wi-Fi, Zigbee, Bluetooth

Switch Function

Relay Switch

Dimensions

0.63 × 1.65 × 1.46 inches

Weight

0.92 ounces

View on Amazon: Shelly 1PM Gen4 Relay Switch with Power Metering Affiliate link

The Shelly 1PM Gen4 is a compact Wi-Fi, Zigbee, and Matter relay switch with built-in power metering. It measures real-time energy usage for connected appliances. The device fits behind standard wall plates and requires no hub for setup. You can control it via voice commands or the Shelly app. It integrates with major smart home platforms. This unit offers precise monitoring for devices like water heaters or space heaters.

Pros

• Wi-Fi, Zigbee, and Matter connectivity
• Built-in real-time power metering
• No hub required for setup
• Compact size fits behind wall plates

Cons

• Non-UL certified version available
• Red color option only
• Relay form factor requires installation behind existing hardware

Good fit if

• You need real-time energy monitoring for specific appliances
• You want a hub-free setup using Wi-Fi or Zigbee
• You are retrofitting existing switches or sockets

Skip if

• You require a UL-certified device for code compliance
• You need a standard toggle switch appearance
• You prefer a plug-in outlet solution

Verdict: Shelly 1PM Gen4 Smart Relay is ideal for users who need detailed energy tracking for hardwired appliances. It suits those installing smart controls behind existing wall plates who want Matter and Zigbee support without a hub.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• ugreen ethernet switch alternatives
• sadotech starpoint extra add on plugin alternatives